You Think You’re So Pretty: What Dove’s ‘Sketches’ Video Got Wrong


“I should be more grateful of my natural beauty” one woman concludes after participating in the Dove Beauty Sketches. In fact, the woman, Florence concludes that natural beauty “couldn’t be more critical to your happiness.”

Florence came to these undesirable conclusions through participation in a commercial released as part of Dove’s campaign to promote “real beauty”. The commercial, titled Dove Real Beauty Sketches is the most viral video commercial of all time, amassing over 114 million views in the month following its release.1 Viewers of the commercial responded with tears, hope for change, and a feeling that this campaign might cause people reconsider the way they look at themselves.2 This initiative was launched in response to company research in 2005 that found only 4 percent of women see themselves as beautiful.2 The campaign, according to Fernando Machado the global brand vice president, is focused on turning beauty from a source of anxiety to a source of confidence. This campaign, and the resulting commercial have two fundamental problems. The first is that it promotes a world in which women should simply see themselves as more beautiful in order to increase their worth, rather than valuing other characteristics that they might possess. Secondly, the basis of their campaign, and reasoning for launching it—that women tend to see themselves as less beautiful than they truly are—is scientifically wrong.

Dove’s “real beauty” initiative, unsurprisingly, combats women’s anxiety about beauty in a way that still promotes the importance of beauty. As a company that profits from the sale of beauty enhancing products, they pair the idea that “you are more beautiful than you think” with the concept that possessing beauty is essential to life and happiness. It seems that Dove is arguing that women see themselves more negatively than they should, at least in part because they are overly critical of their physical beauty. Dove still tells ladies beauty is supremely important to the way they view themselves

In fact, after the transformative experience of the Dove Real Beauty Sketches, Florence finds that her perception of her own natural beauty “impacts everything.” Instead of responding to the finding that beauty is a source of negative affect and anxiety for women, we should argue that there are other qualities women possess which are significantly more important than being considered beautiful. Instead of proving to women that they are worth more than they thought because they are more beautiful than they believe, we should prove to them that their worth is not a constituent of their beauty. Dove has the right intention of reducing anxiety about beauty itself, but it seems their methods also promote it in other, more subtle, ways.

The second, more objective problem with Dove’s Beauty Sketches is the evidence and research supporting their commercial is highly disputed by a large body of psychological scholarship. In a recent article in Scientific American, Ozgun Atasoy3 shows most women see themselves as less attractive than they actually are contradicts the well-established doctrine of “self-enhancement.”

Self-enhancement is the theory that individuals tend to see themselves in a more positive light than is actually accurate. This is corroborated by a recent study conducted by Nicholas Epley, a professor at the University of Chicago and Erin Whitchurch, a professor at the University of Virginia.4 In this study, Epley and Whitchurch took photos of participants and digitally modified them into more, and less attractive photos. Participants were then shown the original photo and modified photos, and asked to choose the photo that they believe is the original. Unlike what the Dove campaign would likely predict (that participants would choose the less attractive photo), participants tended to choose the modified photos that enhanced their attractiveness as the actual photos. Further, when participants were choosing for a stranger, they tended accurately choose the original photo of that stranger from the given set of photos. It seems that people tend to view themselves as more attractive than they truly are, rather than less attractive.

Atasoy continues on to argue not only does research show that we tend to see ourselves as better than we truly are, but most of us see ourselves as better than the average (an obvious impossibility). This extends beyond beauty, to unrealistic optimism and to overestimate our own good behavior. In fact, we even tend to believe that we are less prone to self-enhancement, essentially that we are better than average at accurately assessing ourselves. Though this cognitive mechanism seems harmful, as it causes our representation of ourselves to be different than the truth, many argue for self-enhancement as valuable. Self-enhancement causes individuals to truly believe that they are better than they are, and have better characteristics than they do, which can lead to higher confidence. Confidence is an important factor in credibility, likeliness to be hired for certain jobs, and even for attractiveness as a romantic partner. Thus, it seems that self-enhancement can and does have important practical consequences.

It also seems that the tendency to be optimistic and believe that one will succeed at a higher rate than the average would be an important factor in hope. One will be more likely to believe that circumstances will change and become better for them, and thus will be more likely to continue to look forward and exert effort to change their situation. Hope is an important component in the human desire to continue to exert effort, as we believe that this effort will tend to create positive results. Self-enhancement might be our best defense against giving up, and an important tool in believing in ourselves, even through adverse circumstances. It even seems that knowledge of this premise might be beneficial to Dove itself, as exploitation of it might leave women scrambling to raise their actual attractiveness to their perceived level (though most women would likely believe that they are the minority that is better than average at assessing their attractiveness).

It seems Dove got it wrong. They are promoting a view that in some ways increases anxiety about beauty, all based on the false premise that women see themselves as less beautiful than they actually are. Their commercial shows women that others see them as more beautiful than they see themselves, and thus (as we should base our opinion of ourselves on others’ opinions of us), we should recognize ourselves as more beautiful. A more accurate commercial might have been to show women over-reporting their attractiveness, and overemphasizing the role of their physical features in their overall worth. Then, the subjects they interacted with could counter by emphasizing the other, non-physical qualities that the person demonstrated, and express that this is an important factor in that person’s worth. If Dove’s intention is to emphasize “real beauty,” they should not be proud of Florence’s conclusion that natural beauty “couldn’t be more critical to your happiness,” and should instead place importance on the non-physical, and non-beauty product enhanced aspects of beauty.


Attribution

1“How Dove’s ‘Real Beauty Sketches’ Became the Most Viral Video Ad of All Time”, Laura Stampler, Business Insider
2“Ad About Women’s Self-Image Creates a Sensation”, Tanzina Vega, New York Times
3“You Are Less Beautiful Than You Think”, Ozgun Atasoy, Scientific American
4“Mirror, Mirror On The Wall: Enhancement in Self-Recognition”, Nicholas Epley and Erin Whitchurch, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin


  • someperson42

    The experiment was also set up unscientifically: the sketch artist should have listened to recordings of people describing their own face and others’ faces to a separate interviewer – edited down to include no pronouns, just descriptors – he should have then labeled each drawing with the number of the recording, and the researchers could then group together drawings of the same individual later.

    • http://theairspace.net/ Blake J. Graham

      Valid point. The results of an experiment done for an advertisement are hardly conducted like scientific research.

  • Alexandra Gregorski

    Great article! I completely agree with all the flaws of the Dove sketch (and additionally have problems with the lack of attention to women of culture, perpetuating white privilege and the notion that white is beauty; I digress), but I also think this article fails to acknowledge the historic roots of the problem. I believe that women are worth more than their outward beauty, of course, but couldn’t help getting emotional watching the video because it strikes a nerve. Women in the U.S. are so wrapped up in this culture of appeasement that they fail to recognize how close to the goal they actually are. Sure, we can hold the idealistic notion that women are so much more than pretty faces, but the media tells us differently. It’s going to take a long time for women to recognize that they are so much more than perfect noses and defined cheekbones, but can we really blame them? If realizing that they are outwardly beautiful places women on a better path of self-acceptance, so be it. I can’t criticize any form of self-acceptance, especially in our toxic culture. A small step in the right direction is better than remaining confined by a false perception of self.

Commentary Ticker

  • Data Knows Best: Greatest TV Shows Get Ranked and Graphed
    March 26, 2014 | 10:50 am

    Every argument is better with charts and graphs. Sometimes a little linear regression can provide more insight than a long-winded report. GraphTV tests that theory by plotting the ratings of popular television shows. It all started with Breaking Bad. Data guru Kevin Wu was watching its fifth and final season and couldn’t help but think [...]

  • A Coin-Inspired National Spirit, Hopefully
    March 20, 2014 | 11:56 am

    The Lakota Nation, a group of seven Native American bands in North and South Dakota, voted to make a Bitcoin-like crypto-currency called MazaCoin their official currency, according to Forbes. Programmer and Lakota activist Payu Harris believes that the coin will help the Lakota people gain sovereignty over their land. “To be a truly independent state [...]

  • Smartguns and the Promise of Progress
    March 3, 2014 | 9:50 am

    With the recent Sandy Hook elementary school shooting (and the 44 school shootings since) still relatively fresh in our collective minds, and with Congress empirically unable to do anything to stop gun violence at all, it seems slowing, if not stopping, the gun violence epidemic has fallen on a strange coalition of gun manufacturers, Silicon [...]

  • Watch: Movies Without Imaginary Friends
    January 28, 2014 | 12:56 pm

    If you seriously haven’t watched Fight Club yet (or read the book by Chuck Palahniuk) stop and go do that right now. You’re fifteen years late to the craziest party. Okay, you’ve watched it now? Onwards. A visual effects specialist in New York accelerated himself to Internet fame in mid-January when he edited Tyler Durden [...]

  • The Racism of “Racism”: The Complicated Origins of the Term
    January 17, 2014 | 12:27 pm

    “Racism,” like race, was invented. The term “racism” has done a lot of heavy lifting for anti-racism advocates, helping to frame anyone discriminating by race as misguided. Just as with classism or sexism, not only does the word racism give name to an evil, it helps to create the thing as evil in the first [...]

  • RSSArchive for Commentary Ticker »

Join our mailing list!



Trending on The Airspace